You are here: Home Fitness Industry Community Blog 2009 October 05 Fit Personal Trainers....?

Fit Personal Trainers....?

by Nardine Oakes — last modified Oct 05, 2009 10:23 AM

Do Personal Trainers have to be fit to train other people....?

Fit Personal Trainers……??

 

Mary: “I’m a personal trainer”

Susan: “Wow you must be so fit & healthy!”

 

As a trainer I have had this said to me hundreds of times. There seems to be this obvious assumption that if you are involved with the fitness industry you must be super fit and a health freak.

 

Recently I was flat hunting and when people asked me what I did you would see a look of fear come over their face when I told them. The fear of being judged by me about what they do. I have learnt to read this look very well so now when people ask me what I do I automatically add that I am not a health freak and will not judge them everytime they put something unhealthy in their mouths or don’t do any exercise.

 

So, to my questions: do you have to be fit to be a trainer? And can you ‘look fit’ without actually being fit?

 

What is looking fit? What are the stereotypes placed on trainers?

 

 A client of mine wrote on their screening form that one of their expectations of their trainer was that they wanted them to be fit. This seems like an obvious expectation clients will have. The question is what is looking fit?

 

Trainers come in all shapes and sizes these days, gone are size 8 female trainers and the male trainers with bulging muscles and a 6 pack to match. Don’t get me wrong there are still some of those trainers out there, but there are a lot of trainers who don’t match the stereotypes.

 

There have been times where I have been so busy training other people I have had little time to train myself and I would definitely have considered myself to be unfit according to my standards. Does that mean I shouldn’t be training people?

 

I have also myself looked at other trainers with big bellies and wondered how potential clients would perceive them. Would I want to be trained by someone who looked overweight?

 

Currently there are some gyms out there who are putting their trainers through a fitness test before they can start training people. I like the sound of that in theory as long as it takes into consideration each person and their individual capabilities.

 

Do you agree with the saying “you have to walk the talk ”…….

 

What does ‘Fit’ look like to you? You tell me…..

Would you train with someone who didn't 'look' fit?

 


 

Document Actions

Comments (10)

Steven Gourley Oct 06, 2009 02:50 PM
because I'm fat but I can train people. When it was my only business I was in great shape, but my desk and I often touch and you could probably store a pen in my belly button now. But, I'm a good trainer, and you'd miss out if you didn't train with me coz i'm chunky. So, being old, slower, wiser and fatter I think selecting a trainer who is hot in bike shorts is fools gold. If I couldn't punch a hole in David Tua, would you not want me as your boxing coach? If I wasn't a millionaire should I not be giving you financial advice? If I didn't have the best wardrobe in the world should I not be designing clothes? Maybe we could take all the heavy trainers and melt them down and make two times as many mini trainers. Or, as Billy Connoly proposes we could take all the fat people in the world and feed them to the starving ones eliminating two problems at once. After all, an average weight person is by far the most useful individual on the planet, and the most acceptable to train with too.
Sarah Hobbs Oct 08, 2009 08:51 AM
I guess it comes down to client expectation. For me I want someone who is going to train me and motivate me to get results, this may mean training with me to make me work harder. I would expect they know what they are talking about and yes I would choose someone with experience but also someone that is physically in shape as that is what motivates me! So while this may mean I miss out on someone who is a lot more knowledgeable, at the end of the day I am paying for results and knowledge should be a by product of my training. For me it is about Personal Trainers taking themselves and their business seriously and let’s face it as a Personal Trainer YOU are your biggest marketing tool…
Nadia Buxeda Oct 08, 2009 04:26 PM
I would choose a PT based on how good they are rather than how they look, but if anything I would now probably sway towards one that didn't look perfect. When I was 18 I thought it was easy to be in shape, as a result I had no empathy for my clients that couldn't lose weight. I remember a client asking me what I had for breakfast (obviously wanting nutrition advice), that morning I had had 2 donuts. I was 18 i could get away with it! As you can imagine I had very little in common with my clients. If I was choosing a PT now I would want one that understands that exercise and a healthy lifestyle is a challenge, not one who exercises 8 times a week because they just love it so much. Most clients want someone they can relate to, not a perfect pin-up.
Daniel Speirs Oct 09, 2009 07:05 PM
The best fitness club I've ever worked in was owned and operated by a chap with a very significant waist girth that wasn't primarilly muscular. He remains to this day the best 'membership consultant' I've ever witnessed and a pretty useful trainer as well. Why? Because he took the time to sit down with every prospective member and listen to them, to understand what they wanted to achieve, why it was important to them and then discuss the options that would suit them best. And he actually followed through and made sure all his members actually achieved what they wanted. His focus while training clients was the same - it was all about the client - their goals, the training experiece tailored completely to what they liked and needed. To me its these simple things that work and are sadly so often overlooked. By perfecting these simple basics his members/clients quickly got over any pre-judgements they made about his physical state. If training with a compulsive pie eater resulted in me getting a call up from Graham Henry quicker than training with a tofu muncher would I choose the pie eater? Heck Yes!
Julie South Oct 21, 2009 08:48 AM
As a PT-in-(academic)-training I'm cognisant of the fact I don't have the "look" of how I perceive a PT should "look" and I'm working on that... and I'm well aware that potential clients (and everyone else probably) will look at me and begin to wonder... they'll have no idea that if push came to shove, I could undertake Half Ironman distances in the pool, bike and road... Although my recovery right now would have much to be desired about it, I could still do those... I wouldn't look particularly elegant and my times wouldn't be considered particularly flash - but I'm fit!

Moreover, I'm hoping that my lifetime experience with battling the bulge and having a love/hate relationship with exercise and fitness will mean I can empathise with my potential clients and thus more readily help them achieve their dreams of being fit and healthy themselves.


I DO believe it's important that PTs have a degree of fitness and professional integrity with the path they're asking their clients to walk.
Tim Armstrong Oct 22, 2009 05:03 PM
well i am going to head out on a limb here because i do feel that for the majority of those who join a gym they have one thing in mind... to enhance the way that they look. Now lets not beat around the fact that 9/10 people who walk into a gym will want trainers to stand out. People believe that other becomes trainers only once they have mastered the science themselves. No offence but if i was to walk into a gym with weightloss and toning in mind i would be looking for the fittest and best looking trainer in the place, and most people would personal trainers should be an example of their work.

I am probably slammed left right and centre already but i will go on. Years back when i was once overweight, unfit and unhealthy myself there is no way in christ i would be looking to become a personal trainer. Now i have been through a transformation and i know that things work and i have tested a few things through my journey. When i walk onto the gym floor i feel fit, look fit and people recognise that and often get many asking questions etc, not vain but honest.

The personal trainer status is still to many a 'idealistic role' as automatically with it comes the idea your are fit, healthy and of course equipped with the right knowledge and know how. Not to say that sometimes on the other hand people can be intimidated by this.

Think about someone like Helen Clark talking about surfing? Yeah shes not a looker but would you exactly take notice of what she says?

In all fairness i am going to stick with the approach and opinion that personal trainers should have some level of accomplishment in their personal exercise regime. If you have th edrive, the know how and the right approach help yourself first.
Daniel Speirs Nov 06, 2009 03:32 PM
Not going to slam you for that opinion Tim - keep it coming! The consideration I'd reinforce relates to that old adage 'Assumption is the mother of all stuff-ups'. I would hope that potential clients would choose a PT based on alot more than the PT's appearance. If not then they run the very real risk of choosing a PT that simply trains them exactly the way they train themselves (that may be all the trainer knows), which could be completely ineffective, non-focused or downright dangerous. All a fit/trim looking PT shows to me is that they've been able to find what works for them - it tells me nothing about their ability to help others. PT is a business (to me anyway) that is totally reliant on the ability to focus attention on achieving the specific goals of others, understanding their individual needs and utilising their individual preferences to create enjoyable training experiences leading to long-term results. As every client is unique, the ability to adapt your solution to suit others is mantadory. Appearance tells me nothing about a PT's ability to do this. I wouldnt buy a house or a car on face value - I certainly hope people wouldn't put something of much greater value (their health and well-being) in the hands of someone that simply looks the part. I don't actually think that most people who walk into a gym (for the first time anyway) want PT's to stand out - I think most of them just want the people who work there to make them feel comfortable and then help them achieve whats important to them. P.S. Regardless of looks, if Helen Clark kicked Kelly Slaters arse in the green room at JAWS then I'd definately take note of what she says...
Gerome Garthwaite Nov 09, 2009 08:46 PM
Ok so I am going to come at this from a slightly different angle. How many clients choose their trainer, and how many are chosen by their trainer?

In my experience managing trainers the ones who had lots of clients were the trainers who got out and chatted with the gym members and initiated conversations. The trainers that put all their effort into what they wore, how cool their profile was on the notice board, and how great they looked in their tracksuit were most often to be found in the cafe drinking coffee moaning about how few PT clients they had!

Food for thought...
Sally Easton Nov 17, 2009 09:48 AM
It's unpleasant to acknowledge, but we judge - instantly, often incorrectly, sometimes spitefully, but we can't help ourselves from making assumptions and casting aspersions. We use the line of work we're in, the car we drive, the suburb we live in, the school we attended, the colour of our skin, the clothes we wear, the accent we speak with, the level of attractiveness in our faces and yes - the size of our waist band, to build a picture of the person we're talking to. We continue to make assumptions until we know the truth, which we do by getting to know the person and finding qualities in them that we like.

I think an 'unfit looking' PT can have a very successful business with a strong client base, the same as any other trainer. But I do think that it may take longer to reach success, as those who act on their shallow judgments will be training with somebody else.
Rebecca Nov 29, 2009 11:19 AM
We all have our own perceptions of what fit looks like. I believe that a fit person comes in all shapes and sizes. Sterotyping any sized person is like cutting your nose off to spite your face. If a client wants to know if that PT is going to help them achieve their goals, just talking to them and asking them questions is going to give them a good insight into that trainer. Personally I'd pick a trainer who is a good listener, has a good level of person hygiene, knowledgable, approachable, positive, fun and above all helps me achieve MY goals. Do you have to "walk the talk"? No, but being fit may mean you'll be around longer to help people achieve their goals. Would I train with some who didn't look fit? Yes, as long as they had all the other qualities that I'm looking for.

Login to comment

To make a comment on any of these blogs you need to login. If you are not a member, join now by clicking on the 'Join Free' button.

Membership is free and you can...

  • Get emails telling you about new jobs in your area
  • Get access to downloadable forms and tools to make life easy
  • Find out early about new resources and training that will suit you
  • Take part in industry forums and comment on blogs
Forgot your password?
Weblog Authors

Victoria Fleming

Victoria Fleming

Nadia Buxeda

Location: Auckland
Nadia Buxeda

Ashleigh Seagar

Location: Auckland
Ashleigh Seagar

Sarah Hobbs

Location: Wellington
Sarah Hobbs

Janine Reese

Location: Christchurch
Janine Reese

Liz Horner

Location: Auckland
Liz Horner

Hayden Roach

Location: Wellington
Hayden Roach

MadeleineKyrke-Smith

MadeleineKyrke-Smith

Steven Gourley

Location: Christchurch
Steven Gourley

Nardine Oakes

Location: Auckland
Nardine Oakes

Sally Easton

Location: Christchurch
Sally Easton
 
Web Design: MetaSolutions. -- Web & CMS Development: TheVirtual Ltd.